The Wisdom of Zebras and Giraffes
Chester Liu talks about collaborative relationships in business
How to create a data-based decision-making culture
We can learn a surprising amount from animals, as I discovered recently on my first safari trip in South Africa.
Consider for example the collaborative relationship between the zebra and giraffe, and the lessons this holds for agile, fact-based decision-making.
The giraffe has great height and expansive vision, but it cannot obtain sensory input from the ground. The zebra on the other hand can smell advancing predators at the ground level and see them under trees, but cannot see danger from afar. Conscious of this, the animals forage together, doubly secure in their collaborative defence effort. At the first sight or smell of danger, one will bolt, causing the other to follow.
The folly of top-down
By comparison, traditional corporate decision-making falls short in a number of respects. Firstly, corporates tend to make and drive decisions only from a “giraffe’s perspective”, i.e. from the top down. But companies are essentially two kinds of animals foraging together – executives at the top as well as workers at the bottom – and workers should have the ability to influence action based on their unique perspective of happenings “on the ground”.
Secondly, since top-down decision-making is a fact of corporate life, companies often make decisions based on opinion rather than on fact. Management and executive committees essentially obtain consensus on what actions are appropriate, resulting in lengthy and sometimes imprecise decision-making cycles. But because the facts are not always visible from the top, the executive relies on people on the ground to relay the summary facts to them, to assemble even more summarised, high-level views.
Research shows that most successful companies organise themselves in non-hierarchical ways and demonstrate other ways of ensuring participative decision-making. However, this success is not only dependent on fostering a culture of openness and collaboration, it is also dependent on the tools with which all workers use to analyse information and disseminate insights. Since knowledge is power, there is a strong relationship between a company’s treatment of information and the level of empowerment felt among its workers.
In the area of business analytics this means empowering workers with information. They must be given the tools to assess the state of affairs as relates to their area of the business, make the decisions based on the facts as appropriate to their level in the organisation, rather than on feeling, and communicate the findings to senior management.
This will allow one version of the truth to permeate throughout the organisation, making decision-making less of an argument and more of a fact-based, foregone conclusion.
Leopards that change their spots
Unlike their jungle counterparts, corporate animals can change their ways – although not, usually, without some digging in of heels. So how do we overcome the natural resistance to adopting a culture of distributed, fact-based decision-making?
- With encouragement from the top, a culture prone to territorialism can turn to openness.
- A willingness to take on responsibility at all levels of the organisation begins with giving people easy-to-use and –understand tools that let them discover the data they need to do their job and communicate answers up to senior management with effective collaboration and visualisation tools. Traditional BI tools do not allow this, as they are focused on reporting with inflexible predefined queries, and require serious skills to operate.
- Fears about data security and integrity often hamper efforts to spread the power of analytics throughout the organisation. But people who object to that perhaps don’t appreciate how widespread distribution and alteration of spreadsheet-based data is. It is important to note that business discovery tools using an app model don’t allow changing of source data, only additions – which, if incorrect, only affects that user. And unlike spreadsheets, apps are automatically updated when source data is updated or corrected via administrative intervention. In addition, the app model provides extra data protection in the form of rights-based access as well as other data security and -integrity measures.
The advice we usually give is to start small with business discovery tools that deliver quick results within a department or even workgroup, and to take it from there.
When the penny drops, it will be clear that there is no going back from a fact-based decision-making culture in which a far greater percentage of the organisation shares.
If information is power, getting rid of personal information fiefdoms by empowering a larger base of decision-makers will both allow better quality decisions and result in a more engaged work force, enjoying greater responsibility, clout and happiness in the workplace.
By Chester Liu, director, product sales enablement, QlikTech